Monday, 23 July 2018

The Big Inclusivity Problem in Publishing – and 5 Resources For Those Facing It



I’ve talked before about managing interns at a publishing company. It’s a hugely oversubscribed industry that so many young people are looking to get into. It’s deeply unfair in so many ways – most of the people I encounter are super qualified, with years of (often unpaid) experience under their belt, and are getting themselves into huge amounts of debt in order to land an entry-level job. Almost every intern I work with deserves a full-time job in publishing, but competition even for unpaid positions is brutal.

There are so many barriers to entry – it’s an industry notorious for its elitism and lack of diversity. Over 90% of people who worked in it last year classified themselves as White British, a statistic that is even more shocking when you realise it’s actually an improvement from four years ago, when the figure was almost 94%. And the divide is not just a racial one – whilst I don’t have any official data to back this up, most publishers seem to be privately educated and grew up in or around London. It really hit home last year when I, myself, was held up at a company dinner as the proud product of my company’s commitment to diversity.

Let’s put this into context. I am the middle-class, university-educated, white daughter of a CEO. I was raised by my happily-married parents in a six-bedroom house in a leafy suburb. I got where I am because I walked into jobs offered by family members in high places, and I (allegedly) got my first role in publishing because the interviewer thought I was pretty. I am the very definition of privilege. So why did my former boss think my presence in the office would suffice as ‘diversity’? Because I’m not from Southern England. Because I ‘ass-k’ questions rather than ‘arsk’ them. It made me cringe. I thought of my Welsh Filipino friend, Carly, who dreams of becoming an editorial assistant. I thought of my schoolfriend, Zani, who would give anything to enter the industry but is black and working class, and so is stuck writing website copy for a car firm in Birmingham. I’ll never know the struggles they face every single day.

Considering how left-wing the publishing sector generally is, it seems odd that this would be the case. But with a year’s interning experience usually being the basic requirement for even a poorly paid entry-level position, it’s little wonder that the average publishing professional seems to be Oxford-educated, Caucasian and with a healthy inheritance in their future. After all, it’s an almost exclusively London-centric industry – and who can afford to work unpaid for a year in one of the world’s priciest cities? Hell, I can barely afford to live here and I’m lucky enough to have a paid position.

Don’t get me wrong, we publishers are generally a nice bunch, and we’re all well aware of the problem. We’ve definitely got a long, long way to go (particularly with ethnic diversity), but there is help out there for those struggling to find their place in such an exclusive industry. The lovely folks over at the Northern Fiction Alliance are spearheading a campaign to break the hold London has on the industry with the aim of increasing regional diversity and promoting inclusivity. They’re calling on publishers to do their bit by opening up shop in the North and kicking open doors for brilliant aspiring publishers from outside London. But if you’re currently in the dreaded internship stage of your career, what can you do to make it worth for you?

The Spare Room Project – If you’re looking to complete an internship but live outside of London, consider getting in touch with the remarkable people at the Spare Room Project. I first heard about this through one of our own interns, who wouldn’t have been able to afford to work for us without this incredible initiative. The people who run the project believe that no one should be left out because of where they live, so they match up interns with kind publishing professionals who have spare rooms in London to offer (for free). This is a brilliant scheme that really tackles the problem head on.

Home Sweet Loan – This is a scheme set up by Penguin Random House, and although it’s for employees rather than interns, I thought I’d mention it anyway. They offer all of their employees interest-free loans on rental deposits (even those still in their probation period), which can be paid back monthly through wage deductions. Particularly useful since the average deposit for a London rental is a whopping £1830! FYI: PRH are on of the only publishers to accept interns without degrees, having recently dropped this requirement to be more inclusive.

HarperCollins BAME Traineeship – HarperCollins has been named one of the best BAME employers in the country. Their year-long paid traineeships are exclusively for people of colour. And you don’t even need a degree (or experience)!

Follow @PubInterns on Twitter – This Twitter account is run by two former publishing interns (now publishing professionals) dedicated to ‘fighting the good fight against unpaid internships’. Not only have they been instrumental in challenging publishers who refuse to pay their interns, they regularly tweet information about paid internships and entry-level jobs, as well as offering unwavering support to prospective publishers. Personally, I think unpaid internships are on the way out, but this is a fantastic place to find yourself a paid role until then.

Work experience placements – Rather than committing to an internship, which can be as long as six months or a year, consider a work experience placement of one or two weeks instead. Regional publishers tend to be tiny and unable to commit to full-time paid internships, but they might be willing to offer you a week’s worth of voluntary work.  It’s definitely not ideal, but it’s far better to be able to gain experience nearby and live at home than to relocate to London for no money! Small, local publishers probably won’t advertise work experience, but it can’t hurt to drop them an email and ask what they can offer you.

Post a Comment

© poemstinkdream. Design by Fearne.